Can BJ Upton Turn Things Around?

May 2, 2013; Atlanta, GA, USA; Atlanta Braves center fielder B.J. Upton (2) bats in the fifth inning against the Washington Nationals at Turner Field. Mandatory Credit: Daniel Shirey-USA TODAY Sports

I’ve been as critical as anyone of BJ Upton, and critical of the Braves organization for going after him at such a high price tag, when his career numbers don’t suggest to me that he was worth what he’s being paid.  We all know the downside, and the negatives.  BJ has a career BA of just .251, and the last time that he hit for that average was 2008 when he hit for a .273 average.  BJ Upton has never been a player that has hit for high average, and his numbers in almost every respect are, to be frank, terrible.  Those numbers are worse now in his first year as an Atlanta Brave than they’ve ever been, but I don’t wish to dwell on his numbers just now.  Rather, I have been wondering lately whether or not BJ can turn things around, and what he might be able to do to help the Atlanta Braves in the 2013 season.  I’m a stat geek myself, so I know the sabermetric guys, the statisticians, and the nut-cases who just love to rag on any player not producing for the Braves, will rip me a new one for saying this, but I’m going to suggest to you that as bad as things are right now for BJ Upton, there is still hope that he can be productive and help the Atlanta Braves.

First of all, join with me in at least attempting to set aside all the current bad numbers.  As hard as that is, it is a prerequisite for being able to see how BJ might still be able to help the Braves.  You’ve heard the old adage about how some people cannot “see the forest for all of the trees”, and I would suggest to you that in order to try and look at how BJ can help the Braves, you have to set aside his current numbers for a moment, and look at who BJ Upton is as a player, an athlete, and a person.  Don’t misunderstand me now.  We’ll look at some numbers, because some of the numbers give us hope, and those are the figures I’m going to concentrate on, even though they will have a negative flavor as well.

Let’s look for a moment at BJ’s infield fly percentage (IF/FB) in 2013.  It is currently somewhere around 24%, and has been as high as 29%!  That number is terrible to be sure, and if you look at BJ’s career, you will notice that that number has steadily increased over time.  From 2004 to 2008, his IF/FB was just an average of 6%, but beginning in 2009, we saw his IF/FB increase to 15%, where it hovered around that average up until 2012.  If you’ve been reading carefully, you will already be aware that his IF/FB has dramatically increased this year with the Braves.  Now, all that sounds quite negative, and the numbers really don’t seem to be able to suggest anything else.  I would submit to you though, that a hitter’s tendency to popup to infield fly-balls is often a bad habit of some sort that CAN be corrected!  I’m not going to talk about whether it will be, but hold out hope that it can be.  I know that the Brave’s hitting coach, Greg Walker, is working with BJ on that and many other things.  If anyone can help turn that dismal stat around, I have confidence in Greg.

Some of the problems, in my opinion, with BJ Upton’s swing is that he is having trouble hitting anything effectively that is not smack-dab right in the middle of his wheelhouse.  He has trouble with the slider, and hasn’t hit better than .191 on sliders since 2009.  He has trouble with pitches away, and hasn’t hit better than .190 with those.  Pitches up in the zone?  Sadly, BJ hasn’t hit better than .187 when pitchers go high on him.  I am going to argue that all of those things are completely correctable.  No, I am not suggesting that his swing problems can be corrected, necessarily, to the extent that suddenly BJ becomes one of the most prolific hitters in the NL East.  I am simply suggesting that the we could see him hitting again for the standard .251 career average that he’s been successful at in previous years.  One other thing to note is that generally speaking, when a hitter has such a high IF/FB rate, it can often be attributed to an injury, current or former, that is still plaguing a hitter.  Recently, BJ was hit by fastball delivered by Wade Miley during the sixth inning of Monday night’s 10-1 win over the Diamondbacks.  This was the same shoulder where Upton’s partially torn labrum was surgically repaired following the 2008 season.  The good news is that although sore, the Braves don’t believe there was any further damage.  The question I have though, is whether that shoulder might still be at issue with his current swing, and whether there needs to be some major adjustments rather than minor ones?  I don’t know, but if the shoulder is not the issue, then I still maintain that BJ’s swing problems can be fixed.

BJ Upton is just 28 years of age, and is still a talented, highly athletic baseball player with a great set of skills in the outfield.  The value he adds to the Atlanta Braves defensively is no small potatoes, and if he can just correct some issues with his swing, I still believe the young center fielder can turn things around and get back on track to contribute.  Only time will tell, but I’m going to hold out hope.  As I said at the start of this article, no one has been any more critical of BJ than I have been, but we can all decide to support him the way that Fredi Gonzalez does.  He may never hit at the level of his brother Justin Upton, but they feed off each other.  I think that BJ’s struggles have motivated Justin to play that much harder, and I think Justin’s continued success will continue to motivate BJ to get back on track.  I know he has the support of his fellow Braves, and support from the fan base goes a long way as well.

Topics: Atlanta Braves, FanSided

Want more from Tomahawk Take?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix. Enter your email and stay in the know.
  • Roger Moore

    Play Jordan Schafer. He is outperforming BJ in EVERY offensive category–hitting, walking, stealing–and he’s a good fielder. If the Braves want to have a chance at the playoffs, Fredi needs to start playing the guys who are making contributions. Plus, maybe it will give BJ an incentive to get his act together. At the moment, he’s a complete waste of money.

    • fireboss

      I don’t disagree however the business considerations and Wren’s $75M 5 year commitment to BJ like his $13M a year commitment to Uggla means that at this point in the season any attempt by Fredi – even IF he had the will – to sit these guys would be squashed by Wren. Remember how long Nate McLouth was given a job when he didn’t deserve it? Consider the personal investment Wren has in these guys and that admitting their abject failure would become his own.

      • Michael Nales

        Totally agree

        • gary

          from a rays fan..who saw soooooo many of his physical/mental issues here…not in his makeup to change and his attitude has always been an issue…his infl fly problem is compounded by his strikeout ratios….paid way to much for a 250 hitter that strikeout waaaaaaaaaaay to much

          • fireboss

            Preaching to the choir here. No one who pays attention wanted him here.

  • fireboss

    I’m certain BJ has the talent to turn this around. I’m not sure he has the personal insight to do it yet. He needs to change his stance, shorten his swing and simplify his approach. After six seasons in the majors and at 28 years old that’s a hard pill to swallow particularly when your little brother is doing so much better on the same team. It takes a humble man to say what I’ve done my whole career is no longer good enough. B.J. has shown no indication of such humility. His career with the Rays under one of the most respected managers in the game is rife with examples of the opposite self image. Every player needs to believe in himself but that doesn’t mean having an over inflated ego. Some players start to believe their own publicity and that’s always bad. In BJ’s case it’s his big contract coupled with his brother’s publicity increasing the pressure he puts on himself and forcing him away from what he needs to do. He’s unwilling to become Dom Dimaggio to Justin’s Joe. Until he realizes that’s what he is and changes his approach to match that he’ll continue to struggle.

  • Lee Trocinski

    Hey, I’m a saber guy who was one of Uggla’s biggest supporters last year and still see the light in B.J. He hasn’t let his offensive struggles creep into his defense, which shows some maturity on his part. His complete unwillingness to adjust is by far the biggest problem. Hitting .250/.325/.450 is what he needs to do to live up to the contract, assuming the defense and baserunning holds up. He can strike out 25% of the time, only have an average BABIP, and still hold that line.

  • Bravespop

    I fully agree with both of you… Lee and Fred. BJ’s demeanor alone doesn’t appear as though he wants to make any adjustments. Even the very look on his face suggests a cockiness that misplaced. I heard Joe Simpson say recently how strange it was that when Greg is working with him in BP, he doesn’t poke that heel toward the pitcher, but for some strange reason, does it live. Weird. Yeah, I think a lot of his issues are mental first, and physical 2nd. Attitude.

    Unfortunately, Fred is also right about the money. It’s the politics of the front office, not the clubhouse, that often get in the way. What Frank needs to realize is that most learned fans already see the failures, even before they are admitted.

    • fireboss

      This is not the first time excessive money was invested. Eventually he may become a sunken cost. Unfortunately like Uggla we may be saddled with him until the contract dies

  • Pingback: Fishing the NL East: Bryce Harper Injures Dodger Stadium's Wall; Wall Out 2 Weeks - Marlin Maniac - A Miami Marlins Fan Site - News, Blogs, Opinion and More