Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

Decision Made: We're Shopping for a Starter

“Braves now in pursuit of a front-line starting pitcher”

That’s the headline of Mark Bowman’s new piece today about the Braves.  So apparently the hang-wringing about what to do is over, and the scouting is underway.  There are several opinion bits out about exactly who The Frank Wren & Co. Salvage Works are after, but for sure it will come down to the few guys they believe can do the job of a “front-line starter” (i.e., something between #1 and #3 in the rotation) between now and the end of the year… at least.

There are reports that Atlanta is somewhere between “considering” and “actively pursuing” Jake Peavy (White Sox), Bud Norris (Houston), and Ervin Santana (Royals).  If you’ve followed the Braves for any time at all, though, you’ll certainly know that this team has an unnerving habit of making you look to the left whilst they are working on the right.

As such, we have prepared a fairly comprehensive list for you to consider:  the shopping list for starting pitching.  Some of these guys will be ones that have been mentioned a lot.  Some hardly at all.  Some have been mentioned, yet aren’t likely to be going anywhere.  But in all cases, I give you the reasons they might be moved… or now.  At the end of this, I’ll give you my personal guess as to what Atlanta does.

So with that:  the Mall is Open… I hope Frank has a gift card.

….still a fair chance that Houston is trolling everybody.

….ummm…. make that “See below“.

….that may have been too optimistic, given new reports.  Drop those odds to about 20%.  KC wants the moon.


As you can see, most are not truly viable/available candidates. In my opinion, it boils down to just these guys (in this order):

I believe that Atlanta will attempt to sign Ted Lilly next week once he clears waivers – for depth reasons.  It would not be a major league deal.  If he gets a major league offer from somebody else, he’ll take it.

Lohse has been a very “hot” pitcher over the past two months, with an ERA of around 2.5 over that period of time.  He’s nearly 35, but has been pretty durable.  The contract is acceptable… and if the Braves wanted to spin him off at some point, they’d likely find someone to take him (assuming he’s still pitching well and not hurt).  Either way, the obligation runs only through 2015.

Peavy’s contract is pretty stout.  That’s also why I rank him lower on the list.  Santana, however, would strictly be a rental, though KC would require a stud prospect in return (and recent reports suggest they like what the Rangers paid for Matt Garza as a guideline… very steep price).  So there’s two big reasons why these guys would be (in an ideal world) the lesser targets.

Joe Saunders?  Cheaper for sure, but lesser performance up-side as well:  he does not fit the definition of “front line starter.”

Financially, all of these four can be handled by Atlanta… though Peavy’s deal would certainly stretch that point.  If his contract option doesn’t vest (it probably won’t), then it’s likely the better deal, and I do like the fact that he’s a true workhorse in the mold of Tim Hudson… which, unfortunately means that he’s be getting injured more often lately (though the most recent – a broken rib – isn’t exactly common for pitchers).  Atlanta has had significant interest in him in the past… and honestly:  I think the Braves would prefer Peavy over all others on this list.

But there will be competition:

  • Arizona – would prefer non-rentals.  That means Peavy/Lohse.
  • Boston – definitely looking at Peavy/Lohse/Santana
  • Cardinals – seems the are ‘going for it’ again
  • Marinersseriously?  They can’t buy free agents, so force ‘em to the NWest, I guess.
  • others are possible as well

But will Atlanta pay the price?  That’s a big question… and I bet they don’t know the answer yet.

We’ll see how that all works out.  Five days to go.

Next Braves Game View full schedule »
Thursday, Aug 2828 Aug7:10at New York MetsBuy Tickets

Tags: Atlanta Braves Bud Norris Ervin Santana Jake Peavy Joe Saunders Kyle Lohse Ted Lilly Trade Deadline

  • cheadrick

    I think it may end up Norris based on the numbers and the price. As I said in an earlier post though, I hope not. I personally, and more realistically than many on the list hope Ervin,. I’m praying no Peavy. That’s my .02. Good piece Alan.

  • carpengui

    MLBTR: “The Braves could become a wild card in the Peavy sweepstakes, Jon Heyman of CBS Sports confirms. The current frontrunners for Peavy appear to be the A’s, Cardinals and Red Sox at this time, adds Heyman.”

    Odds that Jon Heyman rumor reports are accurate? 10%

    • cheadrick

      haha you think Heyman’s odds that good?

      • carpengui

        Well, he’s probably right on the Red Sox at least. :D

        Honestly, I think it’ll come down to the best deal to be had…in some combo of prospects and cash

        • fireboss

          Heyan only gets something right if he sees someone else tweet it or it’s so unimportant no one cares. Dude has a 10 year old picture on his twitter page. Egotistical much?

  • carpengui

    **UPDATE: Even more confusion added:

    “Jayson Stark @jaysonst
    Clubs that spoke with #Braves today doubtful they’ll trade for a starter. Adamant about not dealing top prospects. Still more focused on pen”

    >> next tweet doubted pursuit of Bud Norris due to lack of big game experience.

    Kinda hope he’s right – still need a bullpen lefty. If that can be had for cheap enough, then we can talk starters, perhaps.

  • jimfetterolf

    Kansas City could offer a package of Santana and one of Collins/Crow/Hochevar for the right prospects, which cures two of the Braves’ problems.

    • carpengui

      Would be nice to see [useful] guys coming from KC towards Atlanta for a change, eh?

  • fireboss

    Odd of Jared Weaver Moving -50% You couldn’t get Weaver away from the Halo’s if you had Arte’s wife as hostage.
    I’ve looked at this all day and read until I’m blind but there’s a method to Wren unless he “likes” a player then it’s Katie Bar The Door. The most likely guy is often the ;east mentioned guy. We play the Rockies next week. so I’ putting $10 on Jorge De La Rosa.
    Just saw Wren is on the phone and taking multiple calls. Pizza order or. . . .

  • Pingback: Trading Post: So What's Wren to Do? - Tomahawk Take