Oct 27, 2013; St. Louis, MO, USA; The umpires gather on the field before game four of the MLB baseball World Series between the St. Louis Cardinals and Boston Red Sox at Busch Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Eileen Blass-USA TODAY Sports

Will Replay Ruin Baseball?

During the winter meetings, there was a lot of talk about implementing instant replay for Major League Baseball. Could replay be ready for the start of the 2014 season? What exactly will the rules be for “challenging” plays?

The first problem has already risen for replay in baseball. The MLB wants to start using replay in the upcoming season. The problem is, they have absolutely nothing figured out. The rules committee is still trying to decide the number of challenges for managers and what plays can and cannot be reviewed. Why rush the replay system? Just wait until 2015 to get all of the kinks out and implant it then.

To the next problem; Everyone stealing is going to be safe. In the unofficial unwritten rules of baseball, if the ball beats you to a bag, you’re going to be called out. There is no problem with this rule, but replay is going to completely change it. We all know, a player may get a fingertip on the bag before he is tagged a good percent of the time. A manager can challenge the play, and frame by frame will show that the player is safe. This is also going to happen on plays at third, and even at home.

Now, to the “neighborhood” play during a double play. Anyone who watches baseball knows that the shortstop receiving a flip from the second baseman will not stay on (or even near) the bag. Again, this is an accepted unwritten rule, but will replay have to change this? In my opinion, baseball is going to make this unreviewable keeping player safety in mind.

What about all of the bang bang plays at first? Not only are umpires going to be looking at the ball going in the glove and the runners foot, but there is going to have to be an exact rule on what a “catch” is. Does the first baseman catch it when the ball is secured in the palm? Or is it when the ball crosses the plane of the glove going into the webbing? Don’t forget that sometimes the ball wiggles around in the webbing after a catch. I’m afraid baseball is going to get too technical and turn into the NFL with all of the catching rules.

The ruling that will be the biggest mess are plays where a catch is challenged and there are players on base. This can be easier explained in a scenario: A fly ball is hit to deep right center field in AT&T Park. A diving catch appears to be caught, but the team batting decides to challenge the catch. The umpires agree that a catch was not made. This is where the madness happens. How many bases should the batter get? Deep right center field in AT&T park has been home to inside the parkers, so should the batter be awarded home? What if it is Prince Fielder running? What is the arm strength of the center fielder? How many bases should the base runners be awarded? There is going to be too much opinion and controversy in plays like this.

Replay is going to allow for icing the pitcher. Yes I said it, icing the pitcher. Here’s a scenario: Everyone saw Koji Uehara pitch in the World Series. Uehara is now known for getting into a groove and pitching at a quick rate. Need a way to get him out of his groove? Challenge a foul ball that was 20 feet to the left of the line. The umpires will have to review it and get the ruling from New York. Waiting even two minutes for the challenge can take the adrenaline and groove out of a pitcher. It will be a sad day when a game of baseball has to come down to icing the closer.

Notice how I never said anything about the speed of the game. Do you really think baseball wants to speed up the game? Ends of games will be played over scheduled programs with all of the regional television deals. Money is to be made. Baseball makes money for every hour it is televised. Short and sweet, but don’t expect any rules to speed up the game coming any time soon.


Next Braves Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:10Philadelphia PhilliesBuy Tickets

Tags: Atlanta Braves FanSided Winter Mettings

  • Lee Trocinski

    I think replay will help the game. If the frame-by-frame replay shows the wrong call was made, then it should be corrected. As far as the neighborhood play goes, if they were really concerned about player safety, they’d adopt the NCAA rule that the runner has to slide straight into, and not past, the base. It not only keeps the pivot men safer, it also helps the runner (Morneau, Ellsbury). There are some concerns, which you brought up, but getting more calls right cannot be a bad thing for the game.

  • jd

    i only support it if its an in the booth decision only. no coaches challenges. just strictly in the booth and during the breaks that are already built in the game. doesnt take long to review it in the booth without the umpires having to do anything in a replay area

  • http://tomahawktake.com/ carpengui

    All right, I’ll play: Line Drive to CF at AT&T park – got it.

    The premise is that the fielder is ‘selling’ the notion that he’s caught the ball – ergo, it’s not rolling all the way to the wall. The CF has the ball within his grasp. That will pretty much limit the bases awarded to the batter-runner to 1 or 2. It is the responsibility of the runners to react to a play as they see it unfold before them – _not_ as they guess it will be ruled. Any runners on base for such a play must therefore assume that the ball _might_ be caught and insure that they can retreat. That limits the possible outcomes and subjective decisions significantly.

    All that said, let’s suppose an ump rules that a catch is made in this scenario. Runners retreat based on this information. If the play is then overruled later, then is would be correct to allow all runners to advance one base… even if the CF had tried to execute a force-play out (knowing that he actually trapped the ball).

    I will give you a fairly extreme case, though: CF runs down a fly ball to deep center field with Billy Hamilton on 2nd base. Umps rule a catch against the wall. Replay then overrules – showing that the ball was trapped on a bounce off the wall (CF’s body blocked the umpire’s view). I might very well award Hamilton home plate in that instance (particularly if he had taken third base after the ‘catch’)… but then he’s an exception, not the rule.

  • Bryan Allen

    I can solve all of this mess real fast. First, get rid of the DH which is a joke to begin with. 2nd, screw the replay crap. This is a game played by humans, not machines or computers. If ya want that brand of baseball, then play video games. Its a slap in the face of both, the umpires & the players who play the game. And lastly the speed of the game. Look. If ya go to a game & then all your gonna do is bitch about how long it takes to play it, then evidently you either have better things to do than tend the game in the first place, or ya didn’t want to go to begin with, or otherwise you wouldn’t be bitching in the first place. If all your gonna do is bitch, bitch, bitch, then stay home, cos you sure as hell don’t belong in the ballpark. As for getting the call right, we don’t live in a perfect world. And the game is played by humans.So as far as I’m concerned, that’s who should decide it. It seemed to work that way a lot longer & people seemed to be fine with it.So all that said, let the players play, the umpires ump, & the fans watch & cheer. And for the ones who wanna bitch, go watch Justin Bieber cos then you’ll really have something to bitch about.And as for all this high tech instant replay crap, that, can be flushed down the crapper.Baseball is losing its roots. I say its high time we as fans take those roots back.